Structured Interviews in Research
In the realm of qualitative research, interviews stand as a powerful tool for delving into the intricacies of human experiences, perspectives, and behaviours. Among the various interview formats, the structured interview emerges as a methodological approach that combines the depth of qualitative inquiry with the precision of a predefined structure. In this post, we explain what structured interviews are, their defining characteristics, and the benefits they offer to researchers seeking rigour and reliability in their studies.
Defining Structured Interviews:
Structured interviews are a form of qualitative research in which the interviewer follows a predetermined set of questions and a standardized format while engaging with participants. Unlike unstructured or semi-structured interviews, which allow for more open-ended exploration, this format of interview adheres to a specific script, ensuring consistency across all interviews.
Characteristics of Structured Interviews:
- Standardised Questions:
- The core feature of structured interviews is the use of standardised questions that remain consistent across all participants. These questions are carefully crafted to elicit specific information relevant to the research objectives.
- Fixed Sequence:
- Structured interviews follow a fixed sequence, ensuring that each participant responds to the same set of questions in the same order. This uniformity enhances the reliability of the data collected.
- Quantitative Elements:
- In some cases, structured interviews may incorporate quantitative elements, such as Likert scales or numerical ratings, to add a quantitative dimension to the qualitative data. This can facilitate data analysis and comparisons.
- Predefined Response Options:
- Participants are typically provided with predefined response options for each question, offering a standardized framework for recording their responses. This enhances consistency and facilitates data coding and analysis.
- Reduced Interviewer Influence:
- Structured interviews aim to minimise the influence of the interviewer on the participant’s responses. By adhering to a predetermined script, researchers mitigate potential biases introduced by interviewer variability.
Benefits of Structured Interviews:
- Consistency and Reliability:
- The standardised nature of this format of interviews ensures consistency in data collection, leading to increased reliability. Researchers can confidently compare and analyse responses across participants.
- Ease of Analysis:
- The structured format simplifies the analysis process. Data coding and categorisation become more straightforward when responses are organized according to a predetermined set of questions and response options.
- Objective Comparison:
- Structured interviews facilitate objective comparisons between participants or groups. Researchers can identify patterns, trends, and differences in responses systematically.
- Efficiency:
- Structured interviews are often more time-efficient than unstructured or semi-structured formats. The fixed sequence of questions streamlines the interview process, making it particularly suitable for large-scale studies.
- Standardised Data Collection:
- Standardisation in structured interviews ensures that each participant contributes comparable information, enhancing the overall quality and validity of the data collected.
Considerations When Conducting Structured Interviews:
- Pilot Testing:
- Before implementing structured interviews on a larger scale, it’s beneficial to conduct pilot tests. This helps identify any ambiguities in the questions, assess participant understanding, and refine the interview script.
- Interviewer Training:
- Interviewers should undergo thorough training to ensure consistency in their delivery. This includes maintaining a neutral tone, avoiding leading questions, and following the script precisely.
- Balancing Standardisation and Flexibility:
- While structured interviews emphasise standardisation, there should be room for flexibility. Interviewers may need to adapt based on participant responses or provide clarification when necessary.
Summary
The structured format offers a meticulous and systematic approach to qualitative research, striking a balance between standardisation and exploration. Researchers employing this method gain the advantage of robust, reliable data collection while delving into the richness of participants’ experiences. As a valuable tool in the researcher’s toolkit, structured interviews continue to shape the landscape of qualitative inquiry, providing a structured yet nuanced lens through which to understand and interpret the complexities of human perspectives.
Recommended reading
Standardised interviews provide a systematic and validated approach to clinical assessment and diagnosis. This comprehensive handbook presents current, authoritative information on the principal interviews used to evaluate adults and children in a wide range of contexts and settings.
